Do It Anyway Blog Open app

‹ All articles

Why “I have to” makes you not want to

3 min read

You wanted to go for a run. Honestly wanted to. Then you wrote “I have to go running” on a list, and by evening the run had turned into something a stern stranger demanded of you. You stayed on the sofa, on principle. Whose principle is unclear.

This is one of the odder features of being a person. You can spoil a perfectly good plan just by ordering yourself to carry it out.

Nobody likes being told

Psychologists who study motivation have a well-supported idea here: people need to feel that what they do is their own choice. Things we feel pushed into, we do with less energy, give up sooner, or quietly do not do at all. Things we feel we chose, we tend to stick with.

The catch is that the part of you that dislikes orders does not check who is giving them. “I have to” sounds the same from a boss, a parent or your own to-do list.

The task has not changed. Only its grammar has, and that is enough to start a small strike.

Leave the door open

There is a neat finding from research on requests. Across dozens of studies, people agreed more often when the request ended with a reminder that they were free to say no. Nothing else changed. Being told the door is open made people more willing to stay in the room.

The request on its own
The same request, plus “but you are free to say no”
fewer said yesmore said yes
Schematic, not data: the direction found across dozens of studies (Carpenter 2013).

Those studies were about asking other people for things. Using the same move on yourself is our own everyday take, not something that has been tested as such. But it costs one sentence.

Four ways to say it differently

  • Swap the verb and add the reason: “I choose to do the tax form today, because I want my Sunday back.” If no honest reason turns up, that is worth knowing too.
  • Give yourself two options: the dishes now or after the news, the report at the desk or in the café. Both end with the thing done, and you still got to pick.
  • Keep the exit open: “I can stop whenever I want.” Mean it. An exit you are not allowed to use is just another order.
  • Describe instead of command. Not “I must finally clean the kitchen”, but “the kitchen is sticky and I would like it not to be”. A description leaves the deciding to you.

Instead ofI have to do the tax form.

TryI choose to do the tax form today, because I want my Sunday back.

Instead ofI must finally clean the kitchen.

TryThe kitchen is sticky and I would like it not to be.

Two of the four ways, side by side.

Try it on one thing

Take one “I have to” from today’s list and rewrite it as “I choose to …, because …”. Then do it or do not. Either way it was your call this time, and that is a different evening.

In short

  • People stick with what feels like their own choice, and resist what feels like an order.
  • The part of you that dislikes orders does not check who gives them. Your own to-do list counts.
  • Reword one “I have to” as “I choose to …, because …”, and keep the exit open.
Try it on your own thing

Write down what you fear and how sure you are. Do it. Then check. It takes two minutes, and nothing leaves your device.

Starts with an example you can change: Start my tax return

Try it in the app Open the free worksheet

Where this comes from

Read next

This is self-help for everyday situations, not therapy.

New articles as an RSS feed

Need to talk to someone now?

In Germany: TelefonSeelsorge, 0800 111 0 111 or 116 123. Free, day and night.

In an emergency call 112.

In other countries: findahelpline.com lists free helplines near you.