Do It Anyway Blog Open app

‹ All articles

Self-esteem is not built in front of the mirror

2 min read

The standard advice goes like this: stand in front of the mirror, look yourself in the eye and say “I am confident and successful.” The mirror says nothing. You both know about the unopened post in the hallway.

The advice assumes that self-esteem comes first and a good life follows. The evidence for that order is thinner than the number of posters suggests.

What the big review found

In 2003 a group of psychologists went through the research on whether high self-esteem makes people do better, at school, at work, with others. They found little sign that it does. Where the two went together, it looked at least as much as if doing well raised self-esteem as the other way round. Their conclusion was unglamorous: boosting self-esteem directly achieves little.

Why the mirror sentence can backfire

It gets worse for the mirror. In a set of experiments, people who already thought poorly of themselves repeated the sentence “I am a lovable person”. Afterwards they felt worse than similar people who had not repeated it. A sentence you do not believe seems to work less like encouragement and more like a reminder of the gap.

Did not repeat the sentence
Repeated “I am a lovable person”
felt worsefelt better
Schematic, not data: the direction found among people who already thought poorly of themselves (Wood, Perunovic & Lee 2009).

You cannot talk yourself into respecting yourself, for the same reason you cannot talk a friend into it. They want to see something first.

Give yourself something to respect

A long line of research suggests that the belief “I can do things” grows mainly from having done them. Small things count. Three ways to collect them:

  • Keep a done list. In the evening, write down three things you did, however dull. “Answered the landlord. Bought stamps. Went outside.” A to-do list shows what you owe. A done list shows what you are good for.
  • Make one tiny promise a day and keep it. Tiny means tiny: one glass of water, one page, five minutes of the form. The point is not the water. The point is becoming someone whose word counts with you.
  • Talk to yourself as you would to a friend. In studies, people who met their own mistakes with kindness were less thrown by them, and still owned up to their part. You would not call a friend useless over a missed deadline. You would say: that went badly, what now?

Instead ofI am useless.

TryThat went badly. What now?

After a missed deadline: the tone you would use for a friend.

There are more of these, eight in all, in the piece with the self-esteem exercises. No more arguing there, only doing.

Try this tonight

Before bed, write down three things you did today, and one tiny promise for tomorrow. Small enough that you would bet money on it. Then keep it. Leave the mirror for brushing your teeth.

In short

  • Telling yourself you are great does little, and can backfire if you do not believe it.
  • Self-esteem mostly follows from doing things you respect. Small things count.
  • Tonight: write down three things you did, and one tiny promise for tomorrow.
Try it on your own thing

Write down what you fear and how sure you are. Do it. Then check. It takes two minutes, and nothing leaves your device.

Starts with an example you can change: Ask one question in the next meeting

Try it in the app Open the free worksheet

Where this comes from

Read next

This is self-help for everyday situations, not therapy.

New articles as an RSS feed

Need to talk to someone now?

In Germany: TelefonSeelsorge, 0800 111 0 111 or 116 123. Free, day and night.

In an emergency call 112.

In other countries: findahelpline.com lists free helplines near you.