Asking for something when you are sure the answer is no
4 min read
You have a request. A refund for the blender that died after five weeks, a day off, a lift to the airport, a raise. You also have the answer already, because you supplied it yourself: no. So you do not ask, which saves the other person the trouble of refusing and saves you nothing at all.
It is an efficient system. You play both parts of the conversation, lose, and nobody else even has to turn up.
You are probably wrong about the no
In a set of studies, people had to ask strangers for small favours: fill in a questionnaire, lend a phone, show the way to a building. Beforehand they guessed how many people they would have to approach until enough said yes. They guessed far more than it took. Across the studies, people underestimated the chance of a yes by as much as half. Later research found the same pattern in other settings: people who ask underestimate how often others agree.
The explanation the researchers offer is not flattering. When you ask, you think about what a yes would cost the other person: time, money, effort. You do not think about what a no costs them. Refusing someone to their face is awkward, and most people will go some way to avoid it. You of all people should know.
To be straight with you: most of these studies were about small favours between strangers. Nobody has shown that your boss agrees to a raise more often than you think. What carries over is the direction of the mistake. The no in your head is a guess, and guesses of this kind tend to be too gloomy.
Put a number on the no
Before you ask, write down what you expect, worded so that a bystander could confirm it: “She will say there is no budget and look at me as if I had asked for her car.” Then add how sure you are. 80 percent? Now it is a forecast, and a forecast can be checked.
How to word it
- One sentence, with the thing in it. “I would like a refund for this blender.” Not “I was just wondering whether there might be any chance”. If the other person has to dig for what you want, they are tired by the time they find it.
- One reason, not five. Five reasons sound as if you do not believe any of them.
- Leave the door open: “It is fine if that does not work.” Across dozens of studies, people agreed more often when they were reminded that they were free to refuse. It also happens to be true, which makes it easier to say.
- Ask in person or by phone if you can. In one study, a request made face to face worked far better than the same request by email, and the people asking had not expected the difference. An email is easy to send and exactly as easy to ignore.
- Then stop talking. The pause is the other person thinking. If you fill it, you start bargaining against yourself: “or half, or actually forget it”.
Instead ofI was just wondering whether there might be any chance …
TryI would like a refund for this blender. It is fine if that does not work.
Practise on requests that cost nothing
The raise is not the place to practise. Start where nothing depends on it: tap water in the café, a different table, a colleague’s eyes on two paragraphs, whether the shop takes the thing back without a receipt. One small request a day for a week. This ladder is our own suggestion and has not been studied for requests as such. It follows the general idea that easy things done first make harder things look smaller.
- Tap water in the café
- A different table
- A colleague’s eyes on two paragraphs
- Taking something back without a receipt
- The raise
And if it is a no?
Then you have what you had before you asked, plus information. And a no often comes with something attached: “not this quarter, ask me in March”, “no refund, but a voucher”. Decide beforehand how you will pick that up: “If she says no, then I ask what would be possible instead.” If-then plans of this kind are well studied.
Afterwards, read your forecast again. Either you were wrong about the no. Or you were right, and you have found out that a no is one sentence long, usually polite, and survivable.
The only request with a guaranteed answer is the one you did not make.
In short
- The no in your head is a guess, and in studies such guesses tend to be too gloomy.
- Ask in one sentence, give one reason, leave the door open, then stop talking.
- Practise on requests that cost nothing, and decide beforehand what you ask if it is a no.