Speaking up in meetings when your heart is already pounding
4 min read
You have a point. A good one, you think. You wait for the right moment, and while you wait you polish the wording. Then Jonas says roughly the same thing, less well, and everybody nods. You spend the rest of the meeting drafting a speech about who thought of it first.
Waiting makes it worse. With every minute you stay silent, your heart beats a little louder and the bar rises. By minute forty, your first contribution would have to be a small keynote to justify the wait.
Nobody can see your pulse
When you are nervous, it feels as if everyone can tell. Psychologists have tested this with people giving short talks. The speakers rated how nervous they looked, and the listeners rated them too. The speakers regularly believed they looked more nervous than anyone had noticed. In one of these studies, some speakers were simply told about this beforehand. Their talks were rated better, by themselves and by the audience.
So consider yourself told. The pounding is loud on the inside only. And related studies suggest that people overestimate how much others notice and remember of them in general. The half-finished sentence from last Tuesday is being kept on file by exactly one participant.
Say something early, and make it small
A piece of advice that is popular with people who coach this, and to my knowledge not studied: say something in the first ten minutes. It is plausible, because early on a small contribution is perfectly normal, and afterwards you are someone who takes part. Small contributions, in rising order of nerve:
- A question: “What does that mean for the deadline?” Three other people were wondering the same and are grateful.
- Agreement with a reason: “I see it the way Maria does, because that is what the customer asked for.”
- A fact: “We tried that in spring. It took three weeks.”
- And only then the opinion: “I see it differently. I would start with the small version.”
- A question
- Agreement with a reason
- A fact
- An opinion
Write the first sentence down
Before the meeting, put one point on paper, with its first sentence. Add a plan for the moment: “When we get to item three, then I say my sentence.” If-then plans like this are well studied. They take the deciding out of the moment, and the moment is where it usually gets lost.
Keep a second sentence in reserve for when someone talks over you: “I would like to finish that thought.” It sounds bold on paper. Said calmly in a room, it sounds like someone finishing a thought.
About the pounding heart
In one series of experiments, people who said “I am excited” to themselves before a talk came across better than people who tried to calm down. The idea: a racing pulse is easier to rename than to stop. It is one set of studies, so try it rather than believe it. Trying to calm down in a meeting does not have a great record either.
It also depends on the room
Some of this is not you. A well-known study of 51 teams in one company found that teams differed in how safe people felt to raise problems, ask questions or admit mistakes, and that the safer teams did more learning. So if speaking up is hard in your team and easy elsewhere, that is information about the room.
A first sentence does not repair a room in which people get punished for talking. But it tells you whether you are really sitting in one, or only in your forecast of one.
Afterwards, check
Write down beforehand what you fear: “They will think the question is stupid, and someone will roll their eyes. 60 percent.” Afterwards, write down what happened. Usually: somebody answered, and the meeting went on. Most contributions are received as contributions, not as a verdict on the person.
One sentence per meeting, for two weeks.
It does not have to be the best sentence in the room, only one of them.
In short
- Your nerves show less than you think. The pounding is loud on the inside only.
- Say something small in the first ten minutes: a question is enough.
- Write the first sentence down before the meeting, and check afterwards what really happened.