How to start a conversation with a stranger: the first sentence
4 min read
You are at an event. You are holding a glass, and the glass is the only one here you know. Around you stand groups of people who have apparently been friends since primary school. You study the buffet with scientific interest and wonder whether eleven minutes counts as having been there.
The conversation is not the problem. The first sentence is. In your head it has to be witty, original and not strange, and it has to be delivered to someone who clearly wants to be left alone.
What happens when people try it
Researchers in Chicago asked commuters to do one of three things on the train: talk to a stranger, keep to themselves, or do whatever they normally did. Other commuters only had to predict how each would feel, and they expected the conversation to make for the worst ride. Those who actually talked reported the most pleasant one.
A later summary of several studies with strangers found the same pattern in the worries themselves. “I will not know what to say”, “they will not like me”, “I will not enjoy it”: beforehand these were clearly stronger than what people reported afterwards. And after a first conversation, people tend to believe the other person liked them less than that person really did. The researchers call it the liking gap.
Two honest limits. These are averages, and some people have their headphones on for a reason. And the participants were sent by researchers, which is a little different from walking over on your own. Still, the direction is hard to miss: the forecast is worse than the conversation.
The first sentence may be boring
It has one job: to show that you are open to talking. Nobody will remember what it was. What follows is common sense and popular advice, not something anyone has tested line by line.
- The thing you are both in: “How do you know the host?” “Which talk did you come for?” “Have you tried the green stuff?”
- A small question that needs answering: “Is this seat taken?” “Do you know where the coats go?”
- The honest one: “I do not know anyone here. May I join you?” In my experience this works better than it has any right to, because half the room is in the same position.
The weather is allowed, by the way. It has been in service for centuries for a reason: nobody can get it wrong.
Then ask a second question
You do not need material. In studies of people getting to know each other, those who asked more questions were liked more, above all when they asked follow-up questions that picked up what the other person had just said. So: one question, then listen to the answer, then “How did you end up doing that?” The other person does most of the work, and thinks well of you for it.
Know how to leave
Part of the fear is getting stuck. So have the exit ready before you go in: “I am going to get another drink. It was nice talking to you.” Nobody has ever checked whether the drink was fetched.
A conversation you know how to end is easier to begin.
Practise where it is cheap
In one study, people played a kind of scavenger hunt for a week that had them talk to strangers every day. Afterwards they expected less rejection and thought better of their own conversation skills, and that still held a week later. It is one study, but the recipe costs nothing.
- One sentence to someone who is at work anyway: at the till, in the bakery. “Busy day today?”
- One remark to someone waiting next to you, at the lift or the bus stop.
- At the next event: one person, one first sentence. After that you may go home with a clear conscience.
- One sentence at the till or in the bakery
- One remark to someone waiting next to you
- At the next event: one person, one first sentence
Before each one, write down what you expect: “She will answer with one word and turn away. 70 percent.” Afterwards, check. Sometimes she does answer with one word. Then you have lost eight seconds and learned the price of the worst case, which is useful to know too.
In short
- In studies, people expect a conversation with a stranger to go worse than it does.
- The first sentence may be boring. Then ask a second question and listen to the answer.
- Have an exit ready, and practise where it is cheap: the till, the bus stop.